| 
Adriana
Craciun, Fatal
Women of Romanticism.
Cambridge
Studies in Romanticism, no.
54. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 2003. xviii
+ 328 pp. Price.
(Hdbk; ISBN: 0-521-81668-8).
Bibliographic
Citation:
Pratt, Kathryn. "On
Adriana Craciun, Fatal
Women of Romanticism." [date
of access]. Romantic
Circles Reviews 8.
2 (2005): 8 pars. May
2006. <http://www.rc.umd.edu/reviews/craciun_w06.html>.
Table
of Contents
List of Illustrations
Acknowledgments
List of Abbreviations
Introduction
1. The subject of violence: Mary Lamb, femme fatale
2. Violence against difference: Mary Wollstonecraft, Mary Robinson and women's strength
3. "The aristocracy of genius": Mary Robinson and Marie Antoinette
4. Unnatural, unsexed, undead: Charlotte Dacre's Gothic bodies
5.
"In seraph strains, unpitying,
to destroy":
Anne Bannerman's femmes fatales
6.
"Life has one vast stern likeness in its gloom": Letitia Landon's philosophy of decomposition
Notes
Bibliography
Index
Reviewed by
Kathryn Pratt
Auburn University
-
Feminist
inquiry in Romantic
studies
achieves new sophistication
with the publication
of books such as Adriana
Craciun's study, which
addresses the need
for
scholarship on sexuality
in order to supplement
the vast range of works
on gender that have
already
enriched the field. After
the early emphasis on
male writers' representations
of women and, in recent
decades, the recovery
of popular and respected
women writers who had
been written out of
the Romantic canon, critical
attention necessarily
turns to the historicizing
of Romantic feminism. In
other words, recent
developments in feminist
theory demand a self-conscious
critique of feminist
ideology: how do feminist
notions of gender and
sexual difference reify
the women they purportedly
seek to liberate? Examining
how representations
of the body disrupt
normative notions
of sexual difference
at the very moment
of their cultural
enshrinement
in the early nineteenth
century, Fatal
Women of Romanticism offers
a compelling and
timely argument
for the importance
of women's literature
to an understanding
of the cultural
history of the Romantic
Period in Britain.
-
Craciun
addresses the paucity
of feminist criticism
on issues of sexuality
in nineteenth-century
Britain, rightly noting
that the emphasis on
the construction of
Romantic gender roles
has resulted in a naturalization
of sexual difference. Although
she follows Judith Butler
in making this claim,
Craciun enriches her observation
by attending to the history
of this naturalization
in the late eighteenth
century itself: during
this time, the complementary
two-sex model replaced
the longstanding scientific
prejudice that women were
simply inferior versions
of men (the one-sex model). Yet
the ways in which women
writers refused or rewrote
the two-sex model, specifically
through their representations
of the femme fatale, demonstrate
how the effects of sexual
discourse transgressed
the sexual and gender
boundaries that scientific
and cultural hegemony
attempted to uphold. At
once hypersexual and hyperviolent,
the "fatal
woman" figure
subverts the two-sex
ideology that represents
the female sex as naturally
benevolent and passive
in comparison with the
active, violent male.
-
Fatal
Women is
impressive because
its rigorous methodology
combines the best of
new historicist analysis
with a cutting-edge
cultural-studies sensibility. By
focusing on the significance
of literary works, Craciun
avoids the problems
of broad cultural analysis
that cannot hope to
address differences
in textual form and
ideologies of production. In
her use of cultural
materials as context
and evidence, however,
she attends to the political
concerns that continue
to motivate feminist
theory and praxis. By
historicizing Butlerian
notions of sexual difference
within the context
of British Romanticism,
Craciun contributes
to both ongoing feminist
and Romanticist conversations.
-
Craciun
introduces her book
by noting the convergence
of the Romantic femme
fatale and contemporary
theory's attempt to
de-naturalize received
notions of sexual difference. She
argues that women writers'
femmes fatales were crucial
to the development of
these women's poetic identities,
because they challenged
the assignation of mastery
(along with violence)
to men only. Craciun
states her intent to investigate
the very origins of theories
of sex in order to steer
the book away from a simple
application of "postmodern
performative" sex. With
admirable attention to
the genealogy of her approach,
she describes the feminist
critique of the passive
Foucaultian subject by
writers including Grosz,
MacNay, Mackinnon and
Ramazanoglu, and indicates
her own interest in Foucault's
later writing on resistance
as a fertile source for
feminist theory. She
debunks a lingering essentialism
in feminist Romantic studies
through her insistence
on examining "women's
subjectivity as an effect
of power" (8). Androcentric
histories of the femme
fatale figure separate
the violent "unfeminine" woman
from the sexy femme fatale,
but Craciun examines the
power that connects the
two. Mentioning
how "natural" female
nonviolence was used to
bolster ideas of bodily
sexual difference, she
notes, "In
women's violence and destructiveness
we find the end of woman
as a sex" (9).
-
In
the first chapter,
Craciun uses the notorious "mad" matricide
and gifted children's
author and poet Mary Lamb,
with her poetry's interest
in "fatal
beauty," to
establish the link between
the hypersexual femme
fatale and the violent
woman. After
thoroughly explaining
and supporting the ideas
sketched in the Introduction,
Craciun uses her second
chapter to expand her
argument, showing how
British women writers
used the femme fatale
figures of the French
Revolution to historicize
emerging notions of "natural" sexual
difference. A
crucial question for activists
like Wollstonecraft and
Mary Robinson was the
possibility of cultivating
women's physical strength,
although they were thought
to be "naturally" feeble
by proponents of the two-sex
model of sexual difference. In
the next chapter, Mary
Robinson becomes the central
writer under analysis,
as her celebration of
Marie Antoinette provides
a combination of bourgeois
and aristocratic ideals
in an "Aristocracy
of Genius." The
executions of both
queen and antagonistic
female revolutionaries
became in popular narrative
the ritual exclusion
of women from public
life, but Robinson combats
this exclusion in A
Monody to the Memory of
the Late Queen of France,
published after Marie
Antoinette's death, as
well as in writings on
French republican murderesses
and women salonnières. Evidence
from journals and political
tracts provides political
context for the argument.
-
In
Chapter Four, Craciun
turns her analysis
to Charlotte Dacre,
the notorious Gothic
novelist also known
as poet "Rosa
Matilda," and
her portrayal of female
violence and sexual
transgression in novels
including Zofloya and The
Passions. Although
critics have claimed
that Dacre's femmes
fatales reveal her sympathies
with the sexist status
quo, Craciun argues
that Dacre destabilizes
the sexuality of the
female subject through
her pornographic Sadean
heroines, who claim
the power pathologized
in Bienville's (two-sex
model) Nymphomania and
other misogynist scientific
treatises of the period. Chapter
Five discusses poet Anne
Bannerman's femmes fatales
as types of the poet as "magnificent
destroyer," a
formerly masculine ideal. Bannerman
intensifies the mystification
of women seen in Coleridge
and Schiller for her
own poetic ends.
-
The
final chapter takes
perhaps the most innovative
approach to sexuality
in the work of women
Romantic writers by
linking bodily death
and decay to Letitia
Landon's "beautiful" aesthetic. Beginning
with a discussion of the
literary and cultural
display of mermaids during
the period, Craciun churns
through theories of water
pollution, miasma, and
contagion. Reading
poems including "The
Fairy of the Fountains," "The
Mask," and "The
Altered River," she
argues that Landon is
explicitly anti-Wordsworthian
due to her poetic assertions
that "the
will to purity central
to Romanticisms such as
Wordsworth's is unsustainable
and 'In vain'" (226). Using
texts from sanitation
investigations and reforms,
Craciun offers compelling
evidence for Landon's
use of the miasmatic theories
of disease to portray
the corporeal body's disruption
of Romantic transcendence. Various
contemporaneous portrayals
of the unnatural, "undead" female
body in both mermaid
and human form reveal
how Landon's woman is
not all passivity and
death, as in recent
readings like Bronfen's Over
Her Dead Body,
but instead a miasmatic
sexual transgression,
an unnacceptable, dangerous,
yet exhilarating form
of life in a "philosophy
of decomposition."
-
The
pertinence of Craciun's
book lies in its refusal
to provide simple answers
to the complex questions
that motivate current
theorizing about human
sexuality. The author acknowledges the dangers of undermining theories of "natural" sexual difference since, as in the one-sex model that dominated scientific discourse before the nineteenth century, patriarchy often exploits claims of sexual similarity or intellectual "transcendence" of
material circumstance. Fatal Women of Romanticism is
a tightly focused and
controlled history of
the ideology of sexual
difference, and as such
it offers insight into
the history of contemporary
feminist thought. When the field has already been enlarged by so many studies of playful and performative gender in the writings of Romantic women, Craciun's attention to the seriousness of literary "women's work" is
a timely contribution.
Romantic
Circles Reviews
Editors,
Jeffrey N. Cox & Charles
Snodgrass
Associate
Editor, Jeffrey Ritchie
Review
published: March 2006.
Romantic
Circles
- Reviews -
Winter 2006 - Adriana Craciun, Fatal
Women of Romanticism
|